Join my #MindsetMonday Email Club and receive free mini mindset lessons every Monday
PODCAST EPISODE

Is Decision Fatigue Real? What It Means for Your Clients

Dr. Kasey Jo Orvidas explaining how to help clients with decision fatigue on Not Another Mindset Show

If you want to know how to help clients with decision fatigue, start by dropping the idea that they have a battery that runs dry. That tired, can’t-decide feeling at the end of a long day is real. But the research points more toward effort and stress than an empty fuel tank, and those are things you can design around.

Decision fatigue is one of those terms that gets thrown around like it’s a settled fact. If I make too many decisions, then I’ll have a hard time making more, period, end of story. When you actually look at the research, that story changes a little bit.

This episode is a follow-up to my last one on analysis paralysis. The two can feel similar, because both leave you not moving forward in any direction. With analysis paralysis there are too many choices in front of you. With decision fatigue you’ve made so many decisions that you can’t make another one.

If you’re a health or fitness coach, this matters for how you think about your own long days, and for how you help clients with decision fatigue when they tell you they’re out of willpower.

What You’ll Learn in This Episode

  • What decision fatigue is, and how it differs from analysis paralysis and ego depletion
  • What the famous hungry judges study found, and why its results are shaky
  • Why the idea of willpower as a fuel tank largely doesn’t hold up
  • What’s more likely happening when decisions get harder after a demanding day
  • How stress affects your clients’ self-control, and what you can do about it

What Is Decision Fatigue in Clients?

Decision fatigue is the idea that the more decisions you make throughout the day, the worse your decisions get, or the harder it is to make a decision in the first place.

At that point, a lot of us opt for the easier option, outsource the decision to something or someone else, avoid deciding altogether, or get a little impulsive.

The classic version I think of is this. It’s 9pm, you’ve been making decisions all day, you’re tired, and you open up the fridge because you’re starving. You can feel your stomach grumbling, and you literally cannot decide what sounds good. It just feels like, “I can’t make another decision today.”

Decision Fatigue vs. Ego Depletion: What’s the Difference?

Ego depletion is about self-control specifically, while decision fatigue is broader because it’s about deciding. They’re related ideas, but they aren’t identical.

This distinction trips people up a lot, and I see it happen in real time with my students inside the Health Mindset Coaching Certification. Ego depletion is the idea that as you use self-control throughout the day and resist temptations, it becomes harder and harder to keep resisting them.

Decision fatigue isn’t necessarily about resisting anything. It’s about the act of deciding. That’s the clearest way I can show the difference between self-control getting depleted and decision fatigue.

Is Decision Fatigue Real? What the Hungry Judges Study Shows

The most famous real-world evidence for decision fatigue is a lot shakier than it looks.

Researchers looked at over 1,000 parole decisions from eight experienced judges. At the start of each session, judges granted parole around 65% of the time. By the end of the session, that dropped to nearly zero. After the judges had a food break, the number jumped right back up to 65%.

That paints quite the compelling story. Tired, hungry judges hand out harsher justice, and a break with some food seems to restore their ability to say yes.

Unfortunately, the study has a serious problem, and it has nothing to do with fatigue. The cases weren’t scheduled randomly. Prisoners without legal representation tended to be scheduled later in each session, which affects their chances of parole for reasons that have nothing to do with how tired the judge is.

So the drop-off might not be fatigue at all, but who was getting judged last. That’s what researchers call a confounding variable.

This is how I want you to think about research, and real-life situations too. If X seems to lead to Y, are we sure it wasn’t some other Z that changes the story a bit, or changes it entirely? I do this to my own team all the time, to their annoyance, whenever we look at our business data and think we’ve found a clean pattern.

Is Willpower Really Like a Fuel Tank?

Largely, no. The idea underneath all of this is that willpower is like a fuel tank that drains over time as you use it. That’s been tested over many, many replication studies with thousands of people, and it largely does not hold up.

You might be thinking, “Kasey, I know decision fatigue is real. I feel it all the time.” I don’t want to overcorrect and tell you what you’re feeling isn’t real. The everyday experience of being tired and finding it hard to make another decision is real. I get it, I’ve been there.

There’s some evidence that decision quality does seem to shift over a long, demanding day, so the general phenomenon is definitely plausible. The problem is the popular draining battery explanation.

Where the research tends to be heading is that making hard decisions is effortful. Even when you’re tired at the end of the day, deciding what to make for dinner feels like a lot of effort. So over time you may just be less willing to spend more effort, rather than running out of fuel.

From this perspective, your brain is doing more of a cost-benefit check, deciding whether putting more effort in while you’re already tired is actually worth it. That shift changes a lot about how to help clients with decision fatigue.

Why Do Clients Lose Self-Control When They’re Stressed?

When clients are stressed, they temporarily lose easy access to the part of the brain that handles calm, deliberate decisions. They aren’t out of willpower fuel.

When you’re stressed or emotionally flooded, your prefrontal cortex, the big lobe right behind your forehead, gets impaired. That’s where your deliberate decision-making and planning live, the think-it-through part of your brain. It takes a backseat, and your more emotional, reactive brain tends to take over.

So when a client tells you, “When I’m stressed out, I don’t have the self-control to do this,” their battery hasn’t run dry from a day of resisting temptations. That part of the brain isn’t shutting off entirely, but they’ve lost easy access to the part that thinks about their goals, thinks ahead, and makes a decision based on that.

It’s why stressed clients reach for whatever provides immediate relief and temporary comfort. Hello, comfort food. It isn’t a weakness. It’s a shift in your client’s state, which changes which brain system is in charge.

How to Help Clients With Decision Fatigue

The most useful way to help clients with decision fatigue is to stop treating it like a fixed tank and start treating it like something you can design around.

If you really did only get so much decision-making capability and self-control every day, you’d basically be helpless until the tank got refilled the next day. That’s a fixed mindset way of thinking about it, because the control lives in the tank and not with you.

If this is about effort, stress, and emotion regulation, those are all things you have control over. With your clients, that can look like:

  • Setting up their environment so fewer decisions need to be made throughout the day
  • Putting fewer temptations in front of them, so they don’t have to use self-control in the first place
  • Bringing stress coping strategies into the conversation, so they can protect their peace, stay calm, and be more resilient in stressful times
  • Using constraint and removing options, like I talked about in my analysis paralysis episode, so deciding takes less effort

When clients are calmer, they have so much more access to their prefrontal cortex and the decision-making part of their brain.

It also helps to look at the story they’re telling. If the narrative is “I’m just out of willpower, I’m out of decision-making for the day,” that can become their reality. Shifting that belief even a little bit will help.

Key Takeaways: Helping Clients With Decision Fatigue

  • Decision fatigue is the idea that the more decisions you make in a day, the worse or harder your decisions get.
  • Ego depletion is about self-control specifically, while decision fatigue is about deciding more broadly.
  • The famous hungry judges study has a confounding variable, because cases weren’t scheduled randomly.
  • The idea of willpower as a fuel tank largely does not hold up across many replication studies.
  • Harder decisions late in the day are better explained by effort, and by how willing you are to spend more of it.
  • Stress makes it harder to access the prefrontal cortex, which is why stressed clients reach for immediate comfort.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is decision fatigue real?

The experience is real. There’s some evidence that decision quality shifts over a long, demanding day. What doesn’t hold up is the idea that you have a battery of decision-making that drains and leaves you unable to decide.

What’s the difference between decision fatigue and ego depletion?

Ego depletion is about self-control, the idea that resisting temptations all day makes it harder to keep resisting. Decision fatigue is broader and is about the act of deciding, not necessarily resisting anything.

Why do clients say they have no self-control when they’re stressed?

Stress impairs the prefrontal cortex, the part of the brain responsible for planning and deliberate decisions, and the more reactive part of the brain takes over. Clients temporarily lose easy access to that calm, goal-focused thinking, so they reach for immediate relief.

What can coaches do to help clients with decision fatigue?

To help clients with decision fatigue, design around it. Reduce the number of decisions and temptations in their environment, bring in stress coping strategies, use constraint to remove options, and help them shift the belief that they’re simply out of willpower.

You’ve got so much more control than you think, and so do your clients. If you want help getting clear on what you’re actually working toward, grab my free Goal Clarity Worksheet.

Links & Resources

FREE Goal Clarity Worksheet

Health Mindset Coaching Certification

Follow Dr. Kasey Jo on Instagram: @drkaseyjo

Not Another Mindset Show

Research referenced:

  • Danziger, S., Levav, J., & Avnaim-Pesso, L. (2011). Extraneous factors in judicial decisions. PNAS, 108(17), 6889–6892. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1018033108
  • Hagger, M. S., et al. (2016). A multilab preregistered replication of the ego-depletion effect. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 11(4), 546–573. https://doi.org/10.1177/1745691616652873
  • Vohs, K. D., et al. (2021). A multisite preregistered paradigmatic test of the ego-depletion effect. Psychological Science, 32(10), 1566–1581. https://doi.org/10.1177/0956797621989733
  • Maier, M., Powell, D., Murchie, P., & Allan, J. L. (2025). Systematic review of the effects of decision fatigue in healthcare professionals on medical decision-making. Health Psychology Review, 19(4), 717–762. https://doi.org/10.1080/17437199.2025.2513916
  • Arnsten, A. F. T. (2009). Stress signalling pathways that impair prefrontal cortex structure and function. Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 10(6), 410–422. https://doi.org/10.1038/nrn2648

AUTHOR BIO

Dr. Kasey Jo Orvidas, PhD is a published mindset and health behavior change researcher with over a decade of health and fitness coaching experience. She is the founder of the mindset and behavior change coaching program: The Health Mindset Coaching Certification.

  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
  • NEW EPISODES EVERY MONDAY!
THE BEST MINDSET PODCAST FOR
FITNESS COACHES AND ENTREPRENEURS

The Not Another Mindset Show Podcast

Expect research study breakdowns, personal stories, client case studies, and splash of random shenanigans. Allllll with the intent to help you see more growth in your life (and have some fun along the way).

Definitely "not" your typical personal development podcast.

JOIN MY #MINDSETMONDAY EMAIL CLUB

and receive a free mini mindset lesson every Monday

Join my #MindsetMonday Email Club and receive free mini mindset lessons every Monday